Former Middlesex County sheriff found guilty of assault and battery

Former Middlesex County Sheriff David P. Bushey was found guilty in Essex County General District Court on Nov. 19 of misdemeanor assault and battery of a former female employee of the Middlesex County Sheriff’s Office.

In a non-jury bench trial, Judge Julia Hutt Sichol said she found the complainant, Erin Elizabeth Duke of Hartfield, to be “credible.”

Before sentencing, Bushey’s attorney John Singelton asked the judge to take the case under advisement and defer a finding, noting Bushey has moved to Wisconsin. “Don’t hang this over his head,” he said.

Essex Commonwealth’s Attorney James Sitton told the court he was not asking for jail time, and suggested education on how to interact appropriately.

The judge sentenced Bushey to 30 days in jail and suspended all of this sentence for 12 months on conditions that include not having contact with Duke and being of good behavior. Bushey has the option to appeal the case to Essex County Circuit Court.

Bushey, 65, resigned after 14 years as sheriff in March of 2026, citing health reasons.

See more details in our November 25 issue.

Tom Chillemi
Tom Chillemihttps://ssentinel.com
Tom Chillemi is a reporter for the Southside Sentinel.

Stay Connected

6,958FansLike
1,063FollowersFollow
1,743FollowersFollow
101SubscribersSubscribe